ML 55: Every Judge Ranked Itself First
Disclosure: this post was written with the assistance of an AI system (Claude), which wrote the analysis code, ran the experiments and drafted the text. The topic, the constraints, the data choices and the final review are the author’s. Three small arithmetic transformers answered 300 problems on each of three tasks, and each judged all three models’ answers by its own per-character likelihood, with a threshold set so its overall pass rate was right, up to ties....